Im a bit concerned about the pressure coming out from the rocker cover when you remove the pcv valve. There actually should be vaccum at idle if the engine is in a good state. IF you were not burning oil but the crankcase was being pressurized it COULD mean that combustion pressure is excaping past the compression rings but perhaps the oil ring may still be functioning properly and keeping oil under control.
Wipe your finger over the exhaust tip. Is it damp and suity, or completely dry & powdery?
Can we get a snap of your spark plugs? Is that a hard task on these corolla's? That would be the first place id look for burning of oil.
Bookmarks